OK, so I have had a few days to reflect, think and let off steam concerning Utah's 17-10 loss at BYU. I have come to terms that Utah lost the game when they allowed BYU to convert a 4th and 18, from their own 10 yard line, and NOT because of the two horse-shit calls made against Utah right after that play. As you can tell, I haven't completely absolved the referees part in the loss, but after watching the replay of the game can accept the loss.
The two bad calls were Unnecessary Roughness and Pass Interference, one right after other, right after the 4th down conversion. Being at the game and when talking to people right after, I was adamant that they were horrible, horrible calls; the refs were obviously paid off and giving the game to BYU (I'm a Utah fan, what else was I suppose to think). After watching the replay I have toned that down to just 'two BAD calls.' The problem with the unnecessary roughness call was the inconsistency, since almost the exact same thing happened a few minutes earlier against a Utah receiver, without a call... and the safety was in the air to hit the receiver, who did get a hand on the ball. The pass interference, when watched live, looked like the BYU receiver pulled the Utah corner onto him, but after seeing the replay, I think it should have been a no call. The Utah corner had caused the receiver to run the route further out and DID turn to find the ball. The receiver was out of position to get to the ball without cutting back into the corner. (Yes, I understand that my argument could be flipped to defend the PI call, but that is not how I see it.) The corner didn't grab or shove the receiver, only made him run outside of the correct pattern.
Now my biggest problem with the game is that the announcers for the The Mtn. (the Mountain West Conference TV channel) were the two biggest BYU homers they could have assigned to the game. Both are ex-BYU something or other, I felt like I was watching the BYU channel. They sounded depressed when Utah took the lead and jubilant when they came back. I think a conference-wide channel should provide at least a little bit of objectivity to the announcing team.
I can't believe the college football season is